What to watch next if you loved “Should I Marry a Murderer?”
True crime fans have been glued to the recently released British crime series Should I Marry a Murderer, and honestly, we get it. With its shocking revelations, unsettling twists, and the lingering question of how well we ever truly know the people closest to us, it's the kind of series that sends viewers straight down the rabbit hole in search of more.
If you've already finished the series and are wondering what to watch next, Kanopy has you covered. These picks are guaranteed to satisfy your next true crime obsession. Best of all, they're available to stream for free with your library card.
2016 | 4hr 15min
The brutal murder of Isabel Carrasco, one of Spain's most controversial politicians, shocked the nation. Three women were quickly arrested in what appeared to be an inexplicable private vendetta. But as the investigation developed, a deeper story of power, deceit and betrayal emerged.
1994 | 1hr 24min
After her uncle's death is ruled a suicide, filmmaker Lourdes Portillo returns to Mexico to investigate. What follows is a deeply personal exploration of family secrets, suspicion, and the stories we tell ourselves about those we love.
2017 | 6hr 28min
Bill Kurtis hosts "COLD CASE FILES," in which forensic evidence is used to re-examine real criminal cases that have long been considered cold.
Beyond the Headlines: The Tiffany Rubin Story
2011 | 41min
It was every parent's nightmare. On Friday, Tiffany Rubin sent her 7-year-old son Kobe to spend the weekend with his father, South Korean native Jeffrey Salko. On Sunday, Kobe didn't come back.
2018 | 1hr 25min
Ten years after the tragic disappearance and mysterious death of three-year-old Caylee Anthony, her grandparents, George and Cindy Anthony, open up to Elizabeth Vargas about their lives.
2010 | 1hr 35min
When their son is accused of murdering his sister, a mother and father face perhaps the most awful decision any parent could have to make: whether to break with their son or accept him back into the family.
*Access to films may vary.
Ready to uncover your next can't-look-away documentary? Explore these titles and more on Kanopy through your local library. And for even more book, film, and streaming recommendations delivered straight to your inbox, subscribe to Libby Life.
RELATED READ: How to get started streaming films for free with Kanopy
Published Jun 03, 2026
Kiki Faison
Kiki Faison has dreamed of being a writer for as long as she can remember, and today she’s living that dream. When she's not working or volunteering locally, she enjoys exploring nature with her daughter and pup, getting lost in suspense novels, and hunting for treasures while thrifting.