Skip to content
Read & listen online with the Libby app!    Libby logo

The Secrets to a Great Book Club (According to People Who Run Them) | Book Lounge by Libby Season 4

What actually makes a book club GOOD? And how do you get people to come back month after month without turning it into homework? 

This week on Book Lounge by Libby, we're going behind the scenes of the book club. Joe is joined by Amy Allen Clark of Book Gang Podcast and book club, Dave McNally, Adult Services Supervisor at Cuyahoga County Public Library, and Meara of (@mearaisreading) to talk about what makes a great book club, how groups choose what to read, the biggest barriers that keep people from joining and what happens when a book club meeting goes completely off the rails. 

We're talking book club tips, discussion drama, choosing books, reading outside your comfort zone, building community and, naturally, some very important book club gossip. 

Whether you're already a devoted book club person, thinking about joining one or wondering if you should finally start your own, this conversation has something for you. 

And yes, we get into the books that brought people together, the ones that divided them and the stories that have become legendary around the book club table. 

If you're watching or listening on Spotify, comment and let us know: If you're part of a book club, tell us about it! How big is your group? How often do you meet? What's the best book you've ever read together? And, perhaps most importantly, what's the book that nearly started a civil war? 

OR come comment on today's post over on Instagram at @bookloungepod.

Book recommendations:

Who’s in this episode: 

Time stamps:
00:00:00 Title 
00:00:19 Welcome and intro 
00:12:10 Different styles and sizes of Book Clubs 
00:21:48 Preparing for Discussion 
00:47:24 Do you always finish the book?  
01:01:57 What should you know before you walk into book club the first time?  
01:05:52 Comment Question and Outro 

Enjoying the show? Follow Book Lounge by Libby, leave a rating or review, and watch every episode on the Libby App YouTube channel. Find us on Libbylife.com/booklounge 

Got a book recommendation, dream guest or just want to say hi? We'd love to hear from you at bookloungebylibby@overdrive.com. 

Looking for Book Lounge merch? Visit Plot Threads. 

Library friends: Add episodes of Book Lounge by Libby to your digital collection for free in OverDrive Marketplace and Kanopy. You can also purchase the titles featured in today's episode in OverDrive Marketplace. 

Browse our cumulative reading list for the season: https://marketplace.overdrive.com/Marketplace/OneCopyOneUserAndMeteredAccess/SuggestedList/41378
 

Happy Reading! 

Published Sep 28, 2026

Joe Skelley

Joe Skelley has always been a lover of reading and the library. His love of libraries brought him to Libby where he works on the marketing team and hosts the Book Lounge by Libby podcast. Joe loves to read horror, thrillers, magical realism, and the broad spectrum of YA! When he’s not working, Joe’s listening to audiobooks, working on a DIY project, and (most importantly) hanging out with his Boston Terrier, Roscoe.